This blog post explores the historical connections between the medieval academic disputation method and the modern Ph.D. dissertation. It draws on the life of George Starkey, a 17th-century alchemist, to illustrate how Scholastic methods evolved into contemporary scientific practices. The author raises questions about the transition from disputations to dissertations and highlights a need for further research to clarify this relationship. The discussion reflects the author's personal journey of inquiry and the influence of German universities in shaping the modern educational landscape.